On change
The reward in being right
Daphne Bernicker · 3 min read
Have you ever known you shouldn't say or do something, and said or done it anyway? I have. And it didn't go well.
What surprised me, as things were going badly, was the layer underneath the regret. Even though I was upset that things had gone exactly as I predicted, part of me was secretly pleased that I had been right. That secret satisfaction was a reward, and the brain remembers rewards.
Being proven right feels good, even when what we were right about is something we didn't want. That feeling is part of why unproductive cycles are so hard to break. The brain rewards us for being right, whether or not being right helps us.
Why the cycle keeps winning
Think about a team member who says, "I know this meeting is going to be a waste of time," before a meeting they helped make unproductive. Or the CEO who thinks, "If I don't make this call, nobody will," and then collects evidence that nobody made the call. Each time the prediction comes true, the brain gets a little reward, and the cycle gets more entrenched.
There is a peculiar satisfaction in thinking, I knew it. The brain reinforces confirmation, especially when it resolves uncertainty. This is how the brain works, not a personal failing. Once a prediction pays off, even a painful one, we are more likely to follow the same pattern again.
In an enterprise, the belief can even help produce its own evidence. If everyone has learned that the CEO eventually makes the difficult call, they wait. The CEO sees them waiting and thinks: Exactly. If I don't do it, nobody will. What looks like proof may partly be the system adapting to the leader.
Breaking the cycle
The cycle is a loop: a belief drives a behavior, the behavior produces a response from the people around the leader, and that response comes back looking like confirmation of the belief. Because the loop confirms itself, it tends to keep running until one of its parts changes.
Once a CEO can see the loop, they can change one element and watch what happens. If the CEO holds back from making the difficult call, people start to step in. Once they do, the belief that nobody else will has lost its evidence. The loop can be taken apart the same way it was built, one element at a time, and each change shows quickly whether the new pattern is taking hold.
The hard part is that these predictions are often invisible to the person making them. A leader can feel the cycle and still not see the belief underneath it. That is one reason I start with new clients using the EQPlus® Motivation Profile. It quickly shows the motivational patterns driving a leader's decisions, and it gives us a shared language for the conversations that follow, which is where the real work happens. Once a leader can see those patterns, they can work with them instead of being run by them.
The question worth sitting with
Change becomes easier when you understand what you are actually up against. You are fighting a reward system that has learned to prefer a familiar outcome over a better one.
Where is an unproductive cycle showing up in you or your enterprise, and what is it worth to you to change it?
Keep reading
© 2026 Bernicker Leadership Advisory. All rights reserved.